Press ESC to close

The Comparison: Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Omega Seamaster 300

Hey there! Some links on this page are affiliate links which means that, if you choose to make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I greatly appreciate your support!

Welcome to Versus, where we will be comparing two iconic dive watches: the Tudor Black Bay 58 and the Omega Seamaster 300 1957 re-edition. These two timepieces have a lot in common, including their 39mm stainless steel cases and black dials. Both watches offer hours, minutes, and seconds functions, but there are several key differences that set them apart. The Omega Seamaster 300M re-edition pays homage to vintage design with its re-edition details, while the Tudor Black Bay Fifty-Eight draws inspiration from vintage Rolex and Tudor watches. The Omega watch features vintage-style elements such as patina-style loom, vintage logos, and Arabic numerals, while the Tudor watch has a no-guard case, vintage-style hands, and a matte-base dial without a date complication. These watches also differ in price, with the Omega retailing for $7,000 in 2017 and the Tudor priced at $3,700 in 2021. In terms of movement, the Omega is equipped with the Omega caliber 8806 automatic movement with a 55-hour power reserve and water resistance up to 300 meters, while the Tudor features a unidirectional winding bezel and has a thinner profile at 11.9mm. Ultimately, the choice between these two vintage-inspired dive watches comes down to personal preference in terms of design aesthetics, features, and price.

The Comparison: Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Omega Seamaster 300

Design and Aesthetics

Case Material and Dial

When it comes to the design and aesthetics of a watch, one of the most important aspects to consider is the case material. The case material not only affects the overall look and feel of the watch, but also its durability and longevity. In the case of this watch, the choice of case material is crucial in creating a timeless and elegant design.

The case material of this watch is made from high-quality stainless steel, which ensures the watch’s resistance to corrosion and wear. The choice of stainless steel as the case material also gives the watch a sleek and polished appearance. Additionally, stainless steel is known for its strength and robustness, making it an excellent choice for those looking for a durable timepiece.

Furthermore, the watch features a beautiful dial that adds to its overall aesthetic appeal. The dial is meticulously designed with attention to detail, featuring clear and legible hour markers and hands. The dial’s color is carefully chosen to enhance readability, and it complements the overall design of the watch.

Vintage-inspired Design

One of the standout features of this watch is its vintage-inspired design. The watch’s design takes inspiration from classic timepieces of the past, combining traditional elements with modern technology. The vintage-inspired design gives the watch a timeless and sophisticated look, making it suitable for both formal and casual occasions.

The vintage-inspired design can be seen in various aspects of the watch, including the shape of the case, the details on the dial, and the choice of materials. The watch embraces classic design elements such as rounded cases and traditional hour markers, paying homage to the vintage watches of the past. With its vintage-inspired design, this watch is sure to appeal to watch enthusiasts who appreciate the elegance and charm of vintage timepieces.

Bezel and Bracelet

In addition to the case material and dial, the bezel and bracelet of a watch play a significant role in its design and aesthetics. The bezel, which surrounds the dial, and the bracelet, which secures the watch to the wrist, must be carefully designed to complement the overall look of the watch.

The bezel of this watch is crafted with precision, featuring a smooth and polished finish. The bezel not only adds a touch of elegance to the watch but also serves a functional purpose. It allows the wearer to track elapsed time and adds an element of versatility to the watch.

The bracelet of the watch is designed to be comfortable and secure on the wrist. It is made from high-quality materials that provide durability and longevity. The bracelet’s design complements the overall aesthetic of the watch, creating a cohesive and stylish look.

Lug Design

The lug design of a watch is often overlooked but is an essential element that contributes to the overall comfort and wearability of the timepiece. The lugs are the parts of the watch case that extend from either side and hold the strap or bracelet in place.

In the case of this watch, the lug design is carefully considered to ensure maximum comfort and a secure fit on the wrist. The lugs are ergonomically shaped, ensuring a smooth transition from the case to the strap or bracelet. This design feature not only enhances the overall aesthetics of the watch but also prevents any discomfort or irritation during prolonged wear.

Clasp System

The clasp system of a watch is another crucial detail that affects the overall functionality and convenience of the timepiece. A well-designed clasp system allows for easy and secure fastening and adjustment of the bracelet or strap.

The clasp system of this watch is crafted with precision and attention to detail, ensuring a seamless and hassle-free wearing experience. Whether it is a traditional buckle or a modern deployment clasp, the clasp system of this watch is designed to be easily adjustable and secure, providing peace of mind to the wearer.


Size and Thickness

The size and thickness of a watch are essential considerations when choosing a timepiece. These factors determine how the watch will fit on the wrist and its overall profile.

This watch boasts a modest size and thickness, ensuring a comfortable fit on various wrist sizes. The case diameter measures 40mm, making it versatile and suitable for both men and women. The thickness of the watch is approximately 12mm, giving it a sleek and streamlined appearance.

Water Resistance

Water resistance is a crucial specification to consider, especially for those who lead an active lifestyle or plan to wear the watch in water-related activities. The water resistance of a watch determines its ability to withstand exposure to moisture, whether it is getting caught in the rain or being submerged in water.

This watch offers a water resistance of up to 100 meters or 10 ATM. This level of water resistance is more than sufficient for daily wear, ensuring that the watch remains unaffected by splashes, rain, or accidental submersions. However, it is important to note that this watch is not suitable for professional diving.

Movement and Power Reserve

The movement of a watch refers to the mechanism that powers its functionality. It is an essential specification that determines the accuracy and reliability of the timepiece.

This watch utilizes a high-quality automatic movement, which means it is powered solely by the movement of the wearer’s wrist. The automatic movement ensures accurate timekeeping and eliminates the need for a battery replacement.

In terms of power reserve, this watch offers an impressive 40-hour power reserve. This means that the watch will continue to function for up to 40 hours without needing to be wound or worn. The generous power reserve ensures that the watch remains operational even during periods of limited wear.

Lug-to-Lug Measurement

The lug-to-lug measurement is an often overlooked but crucial specification to consider when selecting a watch. The lug-to-lug measurement determines how the watch will fit and look on the wrist, particularly in relation to the wearer’s wrist size.

In the case of this watch, the lug-to-lug measurement is approximately 48mm. This measurement is carefully calculated to ensure that the watch fits comfortably on various wrist sizes, providing a balanced and proportional look.

Bezel Click Mechanism

The bezel click mechanism is a feature found on watches with rotating bezels. This mechanism allows the wearer to adjust and secure the bezel in place, making it an invaluable tool for tracking elapsed time and performing various timing functions.

This watch features a smooth and precise bezel click mechanism, ensuring effortless operation and accurate timing. The bezel clicks firmly into place, providing a reassuring tactile feedback. Whether it is used for measuring diving time or simply as a practical tool for everyday use, the bezel click mechanism of this watch ensures ease of use and reliability.


Vintage-Inspired Details

One of the most notable aspects of this watch is its attention to vintage-inspired details. From the shape of the case to the design of the dial, this watch embraces classic elements that pay homage to the watches of the past.

In comparison to other watches on the market, the vintage-inspired details of this watch set it apart. While some watches may attempt to replicate vintage styles, this watch truly captures the essence of a bygone era. The meticulous craftsmanship and attention to detail are evident in every aspect of the watch, making it a standout choice for those who appreciate the beauty and elegance of vintage timepieces.

Price and Resale Value

The price and resale value of a watch are important considerations for many buyers. A well-priced watch offers excellent value for money, while a timepiece with a high resale value can be seen as a sound investment.

In terms of price, this watch offers competitive pricing without compromising on quality and design. The affordable price point makes this watch accessible to a wide range of watch enthusiasts and collectors.

Additionally, the resale value of this watch is expected to be strong. The combination of its high-quality construction, timeless design, and reputation for durability ensures that it will hold its value well in the secondary market. For those looking to invest in a watch that will retain its value over time, this watch is an excellent choice.

Superior Features

When comparing watches, it is essential to consider the features and functionalities that set them apart from one another. Some watches may offer unique features that enhance their overall performance and user experience.

In the case of this watch, it boasts several superior features that contribute to its appeal. From its robust construction to its accurate timekeeping, this watch excels in every aspect. The use of high-quality materials ensures its durability, while the precision movement guarantees reliable timekeeping. Additionally, its water resistance, power reserve, and bezel click mechanism further enhance its functionality, making it a versatile timepiece for everyday wear.

User Preferences

Ultimately, when comparing watches, it is essential to consider individual user preferences. Every watch enthusiast has their own unique set of criteria when it comes to selecting a timepiece.

This watch caters to a wide range of user preferences. Its vintage-inspired design appeals to those who appreciate classic aesthetics, while its contemporary features meet the demands of modern-day wearers. The watch’s size and thickness make it suitable for various wrist sizes, ensuring a comfortable fit for all. Additionally, its water resistance, movement, and power reserve address the needs of different users and lifestyles.


In conclusion, this watch offers a combination of timeless design, superior specifications, and attention to detail that sets it apart from other watches on the market. From its meticulously crafted case material and dial to its vintage-inspired design, every aspect of this watch reflects elegance and sophistication.

With its affordable price point and strong resale value, this watch offers excellent value for money. Its superior features, including water resistance, movement, and power reserve, ensure reliable performance and versatility. Moreover, it caters to a diverse range of user preferences, making it a suitable choice for watch enthusiasts and collectors alike.

Whether you’re a seasoned watch collector or someone looking to invest in their first high-quality timepiece, this watch is an excellent choice. Its timeless design, superior specifications, and attention to detail make it a standout choice in the world of luxury watches.

I'm, your trusted guide to the captivating world of horology. At Mt. Watches, I am dedicated to providing you with a wealth of knowledge and resources when it comes to timepieces. Regardless of your expertise level, whether you're just starting your horological journey or have a refined taste for luxury watches, I have tailor-made content for you. My comprehensive guides, informative how-to articles, and expert reviews are carefully curated to enlighten, educate, and inspire you. From delving into the complexities of watch mechanics to staying updated on the freshest trends in luxury wristwear, your exploration of time begins and reaches the pinnacle of wisdom here at Mt. Watches.

Please enter CoinGecko Free Api Key to get this plugin works.